Decoding stigma: you have nothing to be depressed about

Harriet Rankin, Time to ChangeWe always talk about stigmatising language, off the cuff phrases and discriminatory terms, but what’s the meaning behind the words? We often attribute misunderstanding, lack of knowledge or even malice to those who use such phrases. But what if we tried to decode them and realise their intention instead?

I've had a think about the various times people have used insensitive or misinformed language in relation to my mental health and I’ve tried to see beyond the initial frustration and anger at their ignorance. Instead, I’ve thought about what they might have been trying to say or wanting to say but didn’t know how.

"You'll grow out of it” = I don’t want to accept that this might be long-term

"I'm fed up of you crying all the time” = It’s hurting me too much to see you like this and I can’t handle it

"But you don’t have anything to be depressed about” = I’m trying to understand why you feel like this but I can’t attribute it to anything concrete. Maybe there’s something you haven’t told me?

"Hahahaha” = I have absolutely no idea what to say. This is awkward and I feel like a total idiot for not knowing how to respond.

"Everyone feels like that at some point” = I don’t want to accept that you’re any different.

"You're too young to have a mental health problem” = I don’t think I can deal with this yet

"What a psycho” = this isn’t like you, and it’s scaring me

"Yeah I’ve felt sad too before” = I’m trying to relate to what you’re saying because then it’s easier for me to empathise and understand

"You’ve changed” = I miss how you were when you were happy, and I hope that person comes back soon

"Are you better yet?” = I hope this is over for you quickly

This might look like merely blind hope or over-optimism. I’m not saying that those who use pejorative language are all well-meaning and simply bad communicators. There are undoubtedly some people who do have stigmatising or discriminatory attitudes imprinted and ingrained. But is that the vast majority?

When I really look back and think about who used those phrases, they are all people who loved me and cared about me. They would never have wanted to add to my pain or make me feel more alone. Yes, the words are fuelled by ignorance, or denial, or miscommunication. But they are also fuelled by feelings. Feelings of helplessness, desperation, confusion, hurt, rejection, anger, and fear. Those in contact with people with mental health problems need support too. Not just emotional support but support on how to communicate their thoughts and concerns in a sensitive and productive way.

I'm a great believer in trying to understand why people act the way they do, not just persecuting them or labelling them as ‘ignorant’. We can’t fight labels with labels! Let’s try and see the person behind the phrase, just as we ask others to see the person behind the mental illness. It’s only through understanding actions that we can start to challenge them, help them, and bring about change.

What do you think about the issues raised in this blog? Share your views with us on Twitter >>

Or pledge to share your experience of mental health today and find out how talking tackles discrimination.


Comments

I really enjoyed reading the

I really enjoyed reading the article Harriet :)

As a sufferer of anxiety and depression, I have come to realise over time who my friends are as they are generally the ones that have asked about my condition to help their understanding.

I also wondered how you came about writing the blog as i am a student myself? It really helps knowing that people our age are fighting a cause that is so present through education.

Hi Heather, I actually work

Hi Heather,

I actually work for Time to Change now, but anyone can write a blog for the website! Here's the link: http://www.time-to-change.org.uk/how-to-blog-for-us. There are some guidelines and tips to help you shape what you want to write.

I agree, we need people of every age to be fighting the battle! We can't do it without each other.

All the best,

Harriet

Labels

Thanks for sharing. I totally am there with some of those comments. They become ingrained in my head. It is very hard as someone else pointed out, when it is a very close family member. I have suffered similar and then have to 'hide' due to the way others cannot handle it in their own family. I think that is the worst bit. They can handle it if it does not relate to them. Such a shame. I particularly found your attacking labels with labels ie ignorance very apt. I agree. Thanks again. I may even post one day. There are so many people with similar stories. At least we have more places to be heard nowadays. That is a good thing.

decoding stigma

Thank you so much for this, the beginnings of thoughts and ideas along these lines have been tugging at my consciousness for a while now... I totally agree we sometimes form a label or even a prejudice about the people who've not experienced poor mental health... fighting labels with labels really doesn't help... It seems to me that learning to listen well is key to making progress on both sides. Great blog. Thank you. :) K

Inappropiate comments

And some more classics Ive experienced
"you would be okay if you worked somewhere else"
" We get a bit stressed sometimes"
" If you dont talk about it, you will forget about it"

Lets hope you are right

I've spent years trying to believe that comments like this from my own mother are well intended. The idea that she cares is so desperately appealling. However trying to look on the positive side and letting myself get hurt repeatedly has pushed me to and over the edge (literally) so many times. It is hard to accept but sometimes people (like my mother) really don't have any good intentions behind the cruel things they say. I'd love time to change to discuss the impact of family members with NPD traits and their impact as I really feel that there is a massive taboo around cutting people out of our lives who continuously make comments that damage rather than improve the mental health of those in crisis around them.

My mothers only emotion is her own anxiety and even when I was at my lowest moments, soothing her anxiety and keeping my situation secret for her sake were all my family spoke about. I was to "not upset" mum because she felt "ashamed of me" and "worried she was a bad mother". She still hasn't asked why I attempted suicide one year on... Its a banned subject and I'd never be allowed back in her house if I mentioned it to extended family. On the other hand she's allowed to tell everyone how "things got a bit much for me" in order to get attention and sympathy.

I hope and pray that relatively speaking I am alone and most people who say such cruel things to relatives feel some empathy behind the mask.

Decoding Stigma

Well observed comments!

Well said Harriet

Obviously, it's not always easy to take this approach when you're feeling low, but I think this is a really good point, and easy to overlook. If we want people to look further than a superficial impression of us, then surely we should be trying to do the same...

how considerate

very helpfull to see things from anothers perspective thankyou for sharing

Post new comment

We require email address to prevent spammers. The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
We need to test you are a human visitor.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

YouTube 60+ videos

Latest video from Time to Change
The stand up kid